The United States–Italy tax treaty establishes a comprehensive framework for preventing double taxation on income, with specific provisions governing how pensions are treated when a recipient moves between the two countries. For individuals receiving state pensions—including those from federal, state, or municipal government entities, as well as public university employees—the treaty provides particular protections and rules that differ significantly from private pension arrangements.
The fundamental principle underlying the treaty is that pensions are generally taxable only in the recipient's country of residence. However, this general rule contains important exceptions and nuances, particularly for government service pensions, which are treated distinctly under the treaty's provisions.
Under the Italy-U.S. tax treaty, government service pensions—which include benefits paid to former employees of the federal government, states, municipalities, and public institutions like universities—receive special tax treatment that differs from private pensions. The treaty recognizes the unique characteristics of these pensions tied to public service, granting specific taxing rights to the paying country.
For government pensions, the treaty generally allows the paying state to retain taxing rights rather than exclusively granting them to the country of residence. This means a U.S. citizen retiring to Italy and receiving a federal civil service pension, state pension, or public university pension would typically have that income taxed by the United States, even if now an Italian tax resident.
A critical provision in the treaty introduces a nationality-based exception: if the recipient is a national of the country of residence (not the paying country), the government pension becomes taxable only in the country of residence. However, for U.S. citizens moving to Italy, this exception rarely applies since U.S. citizenship, not Italian nationality, is the primary factor.
Complicating matters further, the U.S. employs what is known as the Saving Clause, which reserves the right to tax its citizens on their worldwide income regardless of where they reside. As a result, U.S. citizens, whether or not they obtain Italian citizenship, remain subject to U.S. taxation on pension income even after establishing Italian tax residency.
U.S. Social Security Administration (SSA) benefits are treated very differently under the Italy–U.S. treaty. The treaty explicitly states that SSA benefits are taxable only in the United States, even for individuals who have become Italian tax residents.
This exemption reflects the unique nature of Social Security as a social insurance program, not a traditional government pension. Italian tax law acknowledges this distinction and explicitly exempts SSA income from Italian taxation when received by residents of Italy. For beneficiaries, this creates a significant advantage: SSA income is shielded from double taxation entirely.
When a U.S. government pensioner (federal, state, municipal employee, or public university employee) becomes an Italian tax resident and continues to receive pension income from the United States, Italy asserts its taxing rights on this income. Typically, the pension is classified as employment income (redditi di lavoro dipendente) and subject to Italian progressive tax rates, which range from 23% to approximately 47%, including regional and municipal supplements.
However, due to the U.S. Saving Clause, the same pension income is also taxable in the U.S. as source income. Therefore, pension income is taxable in both countries: in the U.S. as the paying state and in Italy as the country of residence. This situation creates a potential double taxation scenario that must be addressed thoughtfully.
To prevent actual double taxation, several mechanisms come into play:
Recent guidance from the Italian Revenue Agency (Agenzia delle Entrate) has addressed the taxation of inherited pension benefits. When an Italian resident inherits and receives a lump-sum distribution from a U.S. pension fund held by a deceased relative, Italy classifies this as pension income to the heir.
Even though such inheritances may be subject to a 10% U.S. withholding tax at source, the lump sum is also treated as income in Italy and taxed accordingly. The Italian authority considers that heirs must be taxed similarly to how the deceased would have been taxed, maintaining the pension classification for tax purposes.
For individuals who spent careers in U.S. government service and are considering retirement in Italy, several key points to consider include:
The treaty framework provides transparency and sets clear rules for government pension taxation. However, the interaction with U.S. citizenship-based taxation means that American government pensioners moving to Italy should expect continued U.S. tax obligations alongside Italian residence-based taxation.
If you're a U.S. government retiree or pensioner moving to Italy, navigating dual tax systems doesn't have to be overwhelming. With ItalianTaxes.com's streamlined, technology-driven solutions, you can file your Italian tax return and manage compliance efficiently and reliably—no paperwork, no unnecessary hassle. Stay compliant with both U.S. and Italian rules, and let our trusted platform handle the complexities so you can enjoy your retirement in Italy with peace of mind.
Sign up for ItalianTaxes.com today and experience the easiest way to file and pay your taxes in Italy—no matter where your income comes from.